Tuesday, August 7, 2007

Mixed Reactions

I finished In Cold Blood this weekend and in the end I think I liked it. Really, it was the last two parts- The Answer and The Corner that made the book for me. I don't seem to have the same problem as Sally and Laura did with the Why. Maybe it is my cynical nature/generation that suggests there does not always have to be a reason. I, like Laura, did not really feel any sympathy for the characters, although I did recognize that the reader was supposed to. I was surprised by how many people in the book were sympathetic to Perry. The trial was absolutely gripping to me. Did they get a fair trial?- I say no. Would they probably be convicted if they had?---yes. Unfortunately, civil rights were not an issue and the defendants were railroaded many times. Nevertheless, it was very interesting to read about. What I liked best about the book was the description of the people involved. Capote was really able to paint a picture. The description of death row and the different killers there really hit home issues about the death penalty and horror of the human psyche/human behavior. I also agree with Tim when he said that there was a shattering of innocence. This was clearly defined in my mind during the trial when Capote wrote that the killing of the Clutter family was not an issue in the majority of the state because of other killings going on. That sounds a lot more like the 21st century than the mid 20th century. Anyway, what I liked least was the fact that I had a hard time believing that there was not a huge amount of artistic license. I mean some parts of the book made me think "he has got to be making this up". Still, in the end, I thought it was a worthy book.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

I agree with Erica about scratching my head sometimes and wondering if, despite his amazing 94% retention rate, Capote was taking some James Frey-esque liberties. This was especially true for me during the scenes where Perry and the other dude, whose name escapes me at the moment, were alone on their trip(s).

Sallyb said...

I think you can be pretty sure that Capote took some liberties. Love that term - "Frey-esque" - Tim. Capote was infamous for being a gossip and for being a tad deceitful.
Look at his relationship with Harper Lee. I'd like to do some research on that because in the film, Capote, there was certainly an implication that she was instrumental in his getting entree and that she may have done some of his research (without getting any credit).

Infobabe said...

Well, Capote did dedicate the novel to Harper Lee and Jack Dunphy, so that shows he cared. Of course the film conveyed his self-absorption, too, when he attended the premiere of "To Kill a Mockingbird" and said, "I don't see what all the fuss is about." That's a pal!